Synchronous Motor vs. Induction Motor: The Definitive Guide
24/12/2024
Sam Nie
Hello every one. This is Sam Nie, the CEO of LUPMOTORS. With 10 year's technical and manufacture experience in the field of 3-phase electric motor, I can provide you definitive guides in the knowledge of 3-phase industrial electric motors,which will help you a lot in selecting electric motors for your applications.
Imagine this: you’re working in a factory, and you need a motor that can power your operations efficiently. You hear about synchronous motors and induction motors, but which one is the right fit? The choice isn’t as clear as it seems.
Synchronous motors and induction motors are the backbone of many industries. Both act important roles, but they differ in how they operate, perform, and suit specific tasks. These differences matter—choosing the wrong motor could mean higher costs, inefficiencies, or even operational failures.
In this guide, I’ll tell all points for you. We’ll explore what makes each motor tick, compare their strengths and weaknesses. Whether you’re new to motors or just looking for a refresher, you’ll find everything you need to make an informed decision. Let’s get started!
Synchronous Motor
Induction Motor
Now, Let’s explore the differences one by one.
| Aspect | Synchronous Motor | Induction Motor |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | Requires a rotor (electromagnets or permanent magnets), a stator, and an external DC excitation system. | Simple design with a stator and either a squirrel cage or wound rotor; no external excitation needed. |
| Power Input | Needs both AC for the stator and DC for the rotor to maintain synchronization. | Operates entirely on AC; the rotor's magnetic field is induced by the stator. |
| Operation Principle | Rotor spins in perfect sync with the stator’s magnetic field, with no slip. | Rotor speed lags behind the stator’s magnetic field due to slip, enabling induction. |
| Speed Control | Maintains constant speed tied to the supply frequency, regardless of load. | Speed varies with load due to slip, offering flexibility. |
| Starting Method | Requires auxiliary mechanisms or systems to reach synchronous speed before locking in. | Self-starting; generates high starting torque directly under load. |
| Starting Torque | Low or zero starting torque; needs external support to begin rotation. | High starting torque, ideal for starting heavy loads without additional mechanisms. |
| Efficiency | High efficiency, especially at unity or leading power factor. | Lower efficiency due to lagging power factor and energy losses from slip. |
| Power Factor | Can operate at unity or leading power factor, minimizing reactive power. | Operates at lagging power factor, leading to higher energy consumption. |
| RPM (Revolutions per Minute) | Fixed and directly tied to the frequency of the power supply. | Variable, depending on load and slip. |
| Cost | Higher initial cost due to complexity and external components. | Lower upfront cost with a simple, rugged design. |
| Maintenance | Requires regular maintenance of excitation systems and other components. | Low maintenance due to fewer components and simpler construction. |
| Industrial Suitability | Best for applications demanding precision, constant speed, and high efficiency. | Ideal for rugged, dynamic, and general-purpose applications with variable loads. |
| Applications | Power generation, aerospace systems, precision manufacturing. | Pumps, fans, compressors, household appliances, conveyor belts. |
Table of Contents
1.Definition of the Synchronous Motor & Induction Motor
1.1 What is a Synchronous Motor?
A synchronous motor stands out for its precision, operating with unmatched stability and reliability. The term “synchronous” refers to its defining characteristic: the rotor spins at the exact same speed as the stator’s rotating magnetic field. This perfect alignment ensures consistent performance without lag or variation.
How it works:
Alternating current (AC) supplied to the stator creates a rotating magnetic field. To achieve synchronization, the rotor requires a direct current (DC) power source. This DC power, delivered through slip rings or permanent magnets, generates a steady magnetic field in the rotor. The interaction between the rotor’s magnetic field and the stator’s rotating field locks the rotor in place, enabling it to spin precisely at a speed tied to the AC supply frequency.
Alternating current (AC) supplied to the stator creates a rotating magnetic field.
A rotating magnetic field is created.
DC power supplied to the rotor.
Achieve synchronization.
This DC power is delivered through slip rings to generate a magnetic field in the rotor.
Synchronous spin.
1.2 What is an Induction Motor?
An induction motor is the powerhouse of simplicity and reliability, widely used for its self-starting and rugged design. Unlike synchronous motors, an induction motor doesn’t require an external power source for the rotor. Instead, it operates on the principle of electromagnetic induction, giving it its name.
Here’s how it works:
Alternating current (AC) flows through the stator windings, creating a rotating magnetic field. This field interacts with the rotor, cutting through its conductors and inducing an electromotive force (EMF) in the rotor. This induced EMF generates a current, which in turn creates its own magnetic field. The interaction between the stator’s and rotor’s magnetic fields produces the torque needed to spin the rotor.
Alternating current (AC) is supplied to the stator.
A rotating magnetic field is created.
This field interacts with the rotor, cutting through its conductors and inducing an electromotive force (EMF) in the rotor.
This induced EMF generates a current, which in turn creates its own magnetic field.
The interaction between the stator’s and rotor’s magnetic fields produces the torque needed to spin the rotor.
A key feature of the induction motor is its asynchronous operation. The rotor always spins at a speed slightly less than the stator’s rotating magnetic field, known as the synchronous speed. If the rotor were to reach synchronous speed, the magnetic field would no longer cut through the rotor conductors, halting the induction of EMF, current, and torque. This slight speed difference, or “slip,” is what keeps the motor running. Because of this characteristic, induction motors are also referred to as asynchronous motors.
Tip: To get more knowledge about the Synchronous Motor, please read this article.
Tip: To get more knowledge about the Induction Motor, please read this article.
Quiz: Test Your Knowledge of Part 1: "Definition of the Synchronous Motor & Induction Motor"
Learn More about Electric Motors?
LUPMOTORS will send you articles to your Email every week.
100% Free! No Credit Card!
2.Core Differences Between Synchronous and Induction Motors
2.1 Structure
Structure of a Synchronous Motor
-
Rotor
The spinning part, often made with electromagnets or permanent magnets. This is what moves in sync with the stator’s magnetic field.
-
Stator
The stationary outer frame, housing windings that create the rotating magnetic field.
-
Excitation System
This provides the rotor with direct current (DC) to produce its magnetic field, ensuring synchronization.
Notice:
Synchronous motors require two power inputs: one for the stator (AC) and another for the rotor (DC). This dual-power setup ensures that the motor maintains its precision, making it ideal for tasks demanding high accuracy and efficiency.
Structure of a Induction Motor
-
Rotor
Squirrel Cage Rotor: The most widely used type, consisting of bars connected by end rings, resembling a hamster wheel. It’s robust and maintenance-free. Wound Rotor: Features windings connected to external resistors, offering greater control over speed and torque.
-
Stator
The stationary outer part of the motor, housing coils that produce the rotating magnetic field.
-
Induction Mechanism
The heart of the motor’s operation. The stator's magnetic field induces current in the rotor without direct electrical contact, making it a marvel of simplicity.
2.2 Performance
Characteristics of a Synchronous Motor
Synchronous motors are renowned for their unwavering precision. Their defining trait? Constant speed. No matter the load, these motors keep running at the same speed as the AC power supply’s frequency. That’s a level of reliability most other motors can only dream of.
Another standout feature is the high power factor. Synchronous motors can operate at unity power factor (or even leading), making them incredibly efficient. This efficiency translates into lower energy losses, which can save big on electricity costs, especially in industrial applications.One key reason behind their high power factor is their ability to adjust the rotor’s magnetic field using external DC excitation. By perfectly aligning the rotor’s magnetic field with the stator’s rotating field, synchronous motors minimize reactive power, achieving unity or even leading power factor. This capability not only boosts energy efficiency but also reduces energy losses in industrial systems.
Summary
Constant speed
High power factor
haracteristics of an Induction Motor
Induction motors are renowned for their durability and adaptability. Their simple construction allows them to handle varying loads with ease, making them ideal for heavy-duty tasks. However, their efficiency and power factor tend to be lower than synchronous motors due to their operating principle. Since the rotor relies on induced current generated by the stator’s magnetic field, there is always a phase difference between the current and voltage, leading to a lagging power factor.
Additionally, the constant slip between the rotor and stator fields results in higher energy losses, lowering overall efficiency. Despite these trade-offs, the ruggedness and simplicity of induction motors often outweigh these drawbacks, particularly in cost-sensitive or dynamically changing applications.
Summary
Durability
Adaptability
2.3 Start Method of the Synchronous and Induction Motor
The way synchronous and induction motors start is a major distinction.
Induction Motors
Induction motors, on the other hand, do not need an external power source to start. The rotor’s magnetic field is generated through induction as soon as the stator’s magnetic field interacts with it. This self-starting capability eliminates the need for additional components, making it more convenient for many applications.
Synchronous Motors
Synchronous motors usually need a secondary DC power source to magnetize the rotor. The DC current is fed into the motor via slip rings to create the rotor’s magnetic field. Permanent magnets can also be used for this purpose. Since synchronous motors require the rotor to operate at synchronous speed to function, an auxiliary startup mechanism is typically necessary. This mechanism brings the motor close to its operating speed before it can sync and begin normal operation.
Impact: The reliance on external power and a starting mechanism makes synchronous motors more complex to initiate. Induction motors, with their self-starting nature, offer a simpler and more user-friendly solution for dynamic or less demanding operations.
2.4 Operational Principles
The way these motors function sets them apart:
Induction Motors
Induction motors, on the other hand, do not need an external power source to start. The rotor’s magnetic field is generated through induction as soon as the stator’s magnetic field interacts with it. This self-starting capability eliminates the need for additional components, making it more convenient for many applications.
Synchronous Motors
The rotor in a synchronous motor rotates at the same speed as the stator’s magnetic field. This direct synchronization means no “slip” (the difference between the rotor and stator speed). The result? A consistent, unchanging speed perfect for precision applications.
Impact:
Synchronous motors excel in tasks where consistent speed is non-negotiable, like in generators or high-precision industrial tools. Induction motors, with their ability to self-start and adapt to varying loads, dominate applications like pumps, fans, and compressors.
2.5 RPM (Revolutions Per Minute)
The way these motors handle speed is fundamentally different.
Induction Motors
Induction motors have a variable RPM depending on the load. The rotor speed always lags slightly behind the stator’s magnetic field—a phenomenon known as “slip.” This slip allows the motor to handle changing load conditions effectively but results in less precise speed control.
Synchronous Motors
The RPM of a synchronous motor is constant and directly linked to the frequency of the power supply. For example, at a 50 Hz power supply, the speed is calculated using the formula:
RPM = (120 × Frequency) / Number of Poles
This precision is a game-changer for applications like clocks, timers, and generators where unchanging speed is crucial.
Impact:
The constant speed of synchronous motors makes them essential for precision-based tasks, while the flexibility of induction motors is ideal for load-intensive applications where slight speed variations are acceptable.
2.6 Excitation System
One of the key differences between synchronous and induction motors lies in their excitation system.
Induction Motors
In contrast, induction motors don’t need an external excitation system. The rotor’s magnetic field is generated through induction—a natural consequence of the interaction between the stator’s magnetic field and the rotor. This self-reliant design is simpler and more cost-effective.
Synchronous Motors
These motors require an external DC power source to excite the rotor. This creates a magnetic field that locks in with the stator’s rotating magnetic field, ensuring synchronous operation. While this setup provides precise speed and high power factor, it adds complexity and cost to the system.
Impact:
The reliance on external excitation makes synchronous motors suitable for applications requiring precision and efficiency but increases initial setup and maintenance complexity. Induction motors, with their simpler excitation mechanism, are more durable and ideal for cost-conscious applications.
Learn More about Electric Motors?
LUPMOTORS will send you articles to your Email every week.
100% Free! No Credit Card!
2.7 Starting Torque
Starting torque refers to the initial torque generated by a motor when it begins to turn from a stationary position. Synchronous and induction motors differ significantly in this aspect.
Induction Motors
Induction motors excel in generating high starting torque. This capability is due to the slip between the rotor and the stator’s rotating magnetic field during startup. The large difference in speed induces a strong current in the rotor, resulting in a high initial torque. This characteristic allows induction motors to start under load without requiring additional mechanisms.
Synchronous Motors
Synchronous motors inherently have low or zero starting torque. This is because the rotor must first be brought to a speed near synchronous speed using an auxiliary mechanism before it can synchronize with the stator’s magnetic field and generate torque. Without this assistance, the rotor cannot align with the rotating magnetic field, and the motor cannot start independently.
Impact:
The difference in starting torque makes induction motors more suitable for applications requiring a direct start under heavy loads, such as pumps and compressors. In contrast, synchronous motors are better suited for applications where precise speed control is critical, but additional equipment is available to facilitate the start.
2.8 Cost and Maintenance
When it comes to cost and upkeep, these two motors differ significantly.
Induction Motors
Induction motors are more affordable upfront and cheaper to maintain. Their simple design and lack of external excitation mean fewer components to fail or service, making them a low-maintenance option for many industries.
Synchronous Motors
The initial investment is higher due to their complex design and the need for additional components like the excitation system. Maintenance also tends to be more involved, requiring regular checks of the excitation system and other intricate parts.
Impact:
Synchronous motors are an excellent long-term investment for precision-critical applications, while induction motors offer an economical solution for general-purpose use.
2.9 Applications
Each motor type has its own niche in the industrial landscape
Induction Motors
Best for rugged, general-purpose applications where simplicity and durability matter. Common uses include:
- Conveyor belts in factories.
- Household appliances like washing machines and fans.
- Industrial tools handling variable loads.
Synchronous Motors
Perfect for tasks requiring precision, constant speed, or power factor correction. Applications include:
- Generators in power plants.
- Aerospace systems needing high reliability.
- Large industrial compressors or pumps requiring consistent operation.
Impact:
Synchronous motors are the choice for high-precision, high-stakes environments, while induction motors dominate in versatile, cost-effective applications.
Tip: To get more knowledge about the Structure of a Induction Motor, please read this article.
Tip: To get more knowledge about the Structure of a Synchronous Motor, please read this article.
Video Resources
Quiz: Test Your Knowledge of Part 2: "Core Differences Between Synchronous and Induction Motors"
3.Advantages and Disadvantages of Each Motor Type
Synchronous Motor
Advantages
-
Precision
The rotor operates at a constant speed synchronized with the power supply frequency, making it ideal for applications requiring unwavering precision.
-
Efficiency
These motors often achieve higher efficiency levels due to their ability to operate at a unity power factor.
-
High Power Factor
Synchronous motors can improve overall system power factor, reducing energy losses in industrial setups.
Disadvantages
-
Cost
Initial investment is higher because of the motor's complexity and the need for additional components like the excitation system.
-
Complexity
The design and operation are more intricate, requiring skilled personnel for installation and maintenance.
-
External Excitation Dependency
3.Requires a separate DC source for rotor excitation, adding to operational complexity.
Induction Motor
Advantages
-
Durability
The rugged design makes these motors highly resistant to wear and tear, even in demanding environments.
-
Simplicity
With no need for external excitation, the construction and operation are straightforward.
-
Cost-Effectiveness
Lower initial costs and reduced maintenance requirements make them a budget-friendly option.
Disadvantages
-
Lower Efficiency
Induction motors consume slightly more power due to their lagging power factor.
-
Higher Losses
Energy losses are more significant compared to synchronous motors, particularly under heavy loads.
-
Slip-Induced Limitations
The rotor speed is not constant and varies with the load, limiting its use in precision-critical applications.
4. How to Choose Between Synchronous and Induction Motors
Choosing between a synchronous motor and an induction motor depends on your operational needs. Let’s break it down based on real-world scenarios.
1. Precise or constant speed on your tasks
If your task demands precise, constant speed, such as driving machinery for intricate manufacturing or powering a generator synchronized with the electrical grid, a synchronous motor is your best choice. Its ability to maintain an exact rotational speed regardless of load makes it indispensable for precision-critical applications. For example, in industries like aerospace or high-tech production lines, where stability and accuracy are non-negotiable, the synchronous motor excels.
2. Handling variable loads on your tasks
On the other hand, if the focus is on handling variable loads with flexibility, such as moving conveyor belts in a factory or running pumps in a water plant, an induction motor is the way to go. Its design allows for slight speed variations depending on the load, which makes it more adaptable. Plus, its rugged build and simplicity ensure it can withstand tough working conditions without frequent maintenance.
3. Size and power capacity
Size and power capacity also play a role. Synchronous motors are often larger and more complex due to the need for an external excitation system. This means they’re better suited for large-scale industrial equipment. Induction motors, with their compact and straightforward design, fit seamlessly into smaller or more dynamic setups, like household appliances or smaller industrial tools.
Ultimately, your decision should hinge on the demands of your application. If precision and efficiency outweigh cost, go for a synchronous motor. If you need durability, simplicity, and a lower upfront investment, stick with an induction motor.
Learn More about Electric Motors?
LUPMOTORS will send you articles to your Email every week.
100% Free! No Credit Card!
8. FAQs
1. What is the difference between induction motors and synchronous motors?
Induction motors rely on a “slip” between the rotor and stator’s magnetic fields to operate, making them self-starting and adaptable to varying loads. Synchronous motors, on the other hand, require external excitation to synchronize their rotor with the stator’s magnetic field, providing precise and constant speed.
2. Is a synchronous motor AC or DC?
A synchronous motor is an AC motor. However, its rotor often requires a DC power source for excitation, which helps generate the magnetic field needed for synchronous operation.
3. Are synchronous motors cheaper than induction motors?
No, synchronous motors are generally more expensive due to their complex design and additional components, like the external excitation system. Induction motors are simpler, making them more cost-effective for many applications.
4. Why does an induction motor never run at synchronous speed?
An induction motor requires a difference in speed (slip) between the rotor and stator’s magnetic field to induce current in the rotor. Without slip, there would be no induced current, and the motor would not work.
5. Why is a 3-phase induction motor self-starting?
A 3-phase induction motor is self-starting because the three-phase power supply creates a rotating magnetic field in the stator. This field interacts with the rotor, inducing a current that generates a magnetic field, causing the rotor to spin without external help.
We offer customized motor solutions to meet your specific application requirements
LUPMOTORS offers ac low voltage 3-phase asynchronous industrial motors of all types – Please contact us freely.
A Selection Guide for Explosion Proof Motors
Learn how to choose the right explosion-proof motor for hazardous locations. Understand classifications, T-Codes, and certifications to ensure safety and compliance!
Structure of Electric Motors | The Complete Guide
Discover the structure of electric motors, from stators and rotors to windings and bearings. Learn how materials impact efficiency, performance, and lifespan!
Motor Thermal Overload Protection | The Complete Guide
“Discover how motor thermal overload protection works, why it matters, and how to choose the right protector. Plus, take our quiz to test your knowledge!”
Brushed Motors vs. Brushless Motors: The Complete Guide
“Explore brushed vs. brushless motors: key differences, pros, cons, and which one fits your needs best!”
How to Test an Electric Motor: Tools, Methods & Procedures
Learn how to test electric motors with expert tools and methods. Discover step-by-step guides for insulation, resistance, and running current tests to ensure peak performance!
NEMA Motors vs IEC Motors: The Definitive Guide
“Explore the ultimate guide to NEMA vs. IEC motors. Learn key differences, efficiency standards, applications, and choose the right motor for industrial success.”
